Insight: Regulated Activity, DBS and Modern Experiences of Work

Post 3: Making informed decisions

In my last post, I said I would explore how Careers Leaders and DSLs can assess regulated activity together.

Why has a relatively narrow change in legislation caused so much confusion and anxiety?

Imagine organising work experience for 200 Year 10 pupils in the last week of June. You’ve found placements, worked with employers, considered individual needs and managed the logistics. Now you’re faced with questions about the activities of potentially hundreds of adults across dozens of workplaces.

Until September 2026, the supervision exemption meant that certain activities involving children could fall outside regulated activity because the adult undertaking them was themselves appropriately supervised.

That exemption has now gone.

This matters because supervision is a normal feature of work experience. A pupil might spend time alongside an employee learning how a job is done, while that employee works under the oversight of a manager or more experienced colleague.

Previously, appropriate supervision of the employee could provide a legal reason why their activities did not constitute regulated activity. Schools could take that into account when considering whether DBS checks were appropriate.

Now, that same employee may be undertaking regulated activity, even though nothing about the placement, the employee’s responsibilities or the workplace’s safeguarding arrangements has changed.

The school must look more closely at what the employee actually does, whether the statutory exceptions and frequency thresholds apply, and what checks are legally available.

And the consequences extend beyond identifying regulated activity. Once a role falls within the definition, Children’s Barred List eligibility and the prohibition on barred individuals undertaking that activity become directly relevant to the safeguarding decision.

Multiply those questions across 200 placements, involving different employers, activities and individual circumstances, and the scale of the task becomes apparent.

The legislative change is narrow, but it removes a route through the assessment that previously mattered to many placements. The underlying activities may be unchanged; their legal classification may not be.

So, before Careers Leaders and DSLs sit down together, let’s establish what the legislation and guidance actually tell us.

What do we know?

  1. The supervision exemption has been removed. An adult can no longer be excluded from regulated activity simply because another adult supervises them. The other statutory tests still apply.
  2. Age matters. The legislation treats employment-related activity involving 16- and 17-year-olds differently. Check the child’s actual age rather than assuming their year group or educational setting determines which provisions apply.
  3. Activities matter, not job titles. Teaching, training, instruction, care and supervision of children are among the activities that can constitute regulated activity. Being named as the placement supervisor does not, by itself, establish that someone is undertaking regulated activity. Nor does simply working alongside a child.
  4. There are statutory exceptions. These include activity involving children that is merely incidental to the same activity involving adults. For example, a pupil might join a training session that an employee is delivering to adult colleagues. The training is intended for the adults; the pupil’s involvement is incidental. That is different from an employee providing training specifically for the pupil. The distinction concerns the nature and purpose of the activity, not simply how long it lasts.
  5. Frequency matters. For these activities, the usual threshold is more than three days in any 30-day period, with a separate overnight provision. The relevant activity need not involve the same child on each occasion. A five-day placement does not automatically mean five days of regulated activity for every adult involved.
  6. Regulated activity establishes DBS eligibility. An adult undertaking regulated activity is eligible for an Enhanced DBS check with Children’s Barred List information. Eligibility does not automatically create a legal obligation to obtain that check.
  7. The barred-list prohibition remains. A barred person must not undertake regulated activity. Knowingly permitting a barred person to undertake regulated activity is also an offence.
  8. There are legal limits on checking. Knowingly requesting a higher-level DBS check without the necessary eligibility is unlawful. A blanket ‘DBS everyone’ approach is not lawful where employees are ineligible for the checks requested.
  9. Schools must make a decision. DfE careers guidance says schools and colleges must decide whether adults working with pre-16 work-experience learners need DBS certificates, consulting Keeping Children Safe in Education.

These are the foundations. They establish what the law permits, prohibits and requires. They do not provide a ready-made answer for every work-experience placement.

So what should Careers Leaders and DSLs do together?

Start by establishing the facts of the placement. What will the pupil actually be doing? Which adults will be involved? What activities will they undertake with children, and how frequently? What safeguarding arrangements does the employer have in place?

Apply the statutory definition to those facts. Where information is missing or an activity is difficult to classify, identify the uncertainty rather than disguising it as certainty.

Then consider the safeguarding decision. What do we know about the pupil’s individual circumstances and needs? What support and protective arrangements will be in place? Which DBS checks are legally available? What additional safeguards might be appropriate?

These are connected questions, but they are not the same question. Whether an adult undertakes regulated activity is determined by the legislation. Whether an available check should be sought requires consideration of the safeguarding circumstances and applicable duties.

This is where professional judgement matters.

I have attended countless safeguarding meetings where experienced professionals have considered the same evidence and reached different conclusions. They have challenged one another, invited alternative perspectives and sometimes changed their minds.

That isn’t a failure of safeguarding. It is an essential part of making informed decisions.

There are certainly wrong answers. A decision might misunderstand the law, overlook important evidence or rely on an indefensible assumption. But there isn’t necessarily one correct professional judgement in every circumstance.

The same principle applies to safeguarding supervision. A supervisor doesn’t simply assess whether a DSL’s decisions were right or wrong. They explore the thinking behind those decisions, challenge assumptions and help the practitioner consider what they might have missed.

Careers Leaders and DSLs should approach work-experience decisions in that spirit. The Careers Leader brings knowledge of the placement, its educational purpose and practical arrangements. The DSL brings safeguarding expertise. Both should be prepared to explain their reasoning, listen to challenge and reconsider their conclusions.

For schools organising hundreds of placements, this needs to be a structured, proportionate and manageable process. Consistent questions and clear records can support that process without pretending that every placement presents identical circumstances.

The aim is not to eliminate uncertainty. It is to make informed safeguarding decisions that can withstand professional challenge, and to record the reasoning behind them.

In my next post, I’ll turn to the employers who offer these opportunities, and what they need to understand about regulated activity and DBS.

Shared post

Scroll to Top