Insight: Regulated Activity, DBS and Modern Experiences of Work

Post 2: DBS? Why the sudden fuss?


The legislative change is narrow. From September 2026, the supervision exemption for regulated activity with children was removed. That’s it. That’s the change. So how has one tiny pebble caused so many ripples?
If social media is any barometer, discussions about work experience are confused — and confusing. Confident, contradictory interpretations abound. But there is more clarity in the guidance than some of the discussion suggests.
What do we know?
DBS guidance establishes which checks are available. Where an adult undertakes regulated activity with children, the role is eligible for an Enhanced DBS check with Children’s Barred List information. Certain activities undertaken more than once, but below the regulated-activity frequency threshold, are eligible for an Enhanced check without barred-list information.
DfE’s careers guidance says schools and colleges must decide whether adults working with pre-16 work experience learners need DBS checks. It directs them to KCSIE.
KCSIE says schools should ensure that placement providers have arrangements to protect children from harm. It explains when work-experience supervision constitutes regulated activity and makes clear that barred individuals must not undertake it.
These sources aren’t contradictory. DBS establishes the checking route, DfE directs schools to make a decision, and KCSIE provides the safeguarding framework.
What don’t we know?
The guidance doesn’t fully explain how schools and external employers should manage the checking process. Who applies? Who pays? What assurance should the school seek? What information can appropriately be shared, and with whom?
KCSIE doesn’t expressly require schools to obtain DBS certificates for every external supervisor undertaking regulated activity. Nor does it remove their responsibility to make a defensible safeguarding decision.
I’ve asked DBS, DfE and the Careers & Enterprise Company for clarification. I’ll share what I learn when I get their replies.
What should schools do meanwhile?
Ardea’s advice is to agree with employers how schools will be assured that adults undertaking regulated activity are not barred. An employer might arrange the appropriate check and confirm the outcome without sharing the certificate or its contents. Schools don’t automatically have a right to that information.
Where satisfactory assurance cannot be obtained, any decision to proceed should require a robust, recorded safeguarding rationale and Headteacher agreement. That is Ardea’s professional recommendation, not an additional statutory requirement.
Careers Leaders should book a proper meeting with their DSL. Explore the legislation together, establish with employers what adults will actually do, how often and in what circumstances, and agree how decisions will be recorded.
Then find an engaged employer and pilot a worthwhile placement involving regulated activity. Work through the checking arrangements together and learn from the difficulties rather than redesigning the experience simply to avoid the definition.
But remember that a DBS check doesn’t mean somebody is safe.
Every adult in a workplace could have a certificate with nothing disclosed while misogyny, bullying or sexualised banter go unchallenged. Do all those DBS checks make the placement safe?
DBS information matters, sometimes enormously. But safeguarding also requires judgement about what a particular child will experience in a particular workplace.
There isn’t one answer that fits every placement. Make thoughtful, proportionate and defensible decisions while we seek greater clarity.
Next, I’ll explore how Careers Leaders and DSLs can assess regulated activity together using realistic work-experience scenarios.

Scroll to Top