Post 4: The Employers’ Perspective
This is the fourth in my series exploring the changes to regulated activity and DBS checks for work experience. This time, I want to consider the employers who provide placements, and how Careers Leaders can explain the changes without making work experience seem more complicated or intimidating than it needs to be.
There is a second purpose, too. I’ve seen how difficult Careers Leaders are finding it to navigate the changes and the sometimes apparently contradictory advice surrounding them. Working through how we explain something to somebody else can be a useful way of clarifying our own understanding.
I’m not offering a definitive interpretation of every possible placement. I’m suggesting a practical approach, informed by the legislation and guidance, that Careers Leaders can adapt to their own circumstances and discuss with their school’s safeguarding lead.
Put Yourself in the Employer’s Shoes
Imagine you’ve run a garage for twenty years. Every summer, you welcome a Year 10 pupil for a week’s work experience. You enjoy doing it, your employees enjoy it, and occasionally you meet a young person who might become a future apprentice. You’ve never had any particular difficulty with the arrangements.
Then an email arrives from a school asking about regulated activity, DBS checks and the Children’s Barred List. You’ve never heard of regulated activity. Nobody has asked you for these checks before. You’re offering to help a local school, and suddenly it feels complicated, potentially expensive and rather risky. Would you think twice about offering another placement? I would.
Schools need to recognise that perspective. The language of safeguarding is familiar to those working in education, but there is no reason to expect employers to understand it. We need to explain what has changed, why we’re asking questions and what we might need employers to do.
What Has Changed?
Schools have a responsibility to safeguard their pupils, including when they are out on work experience. The law also sets restrictions on the activities that people who have been barred from working with children are allowed to undertake.
Until September 2026, an adult teaching, training or supervising a child could sometimes fall outside certain safeguarding rules because another suitable adult was supervising that adult. This was known as the supervision exemption. That exemption has now been removed.
The change means that schools need to consider carefully what adults working with their pupils will actually be doing. Some activities, including teaching, training, instructing, caring for or supervising children, can fall within a legal category called regulated activity. People who have been barred from working with children are not permitted to undertake regulated activity.
This doesn’t mean that everyone who works alongside a pupil needs a DBS check. Whether an adult is undertaking regulated activity depends on the nature of what they’re doing, the arrangements under which they’re doing it and, in many circumstances, how frequently they do it. For some activities, the relevant frequency is four or more days within a 30-day period. Other circumstances and exceptions may also apply.
Consider an employee carrying out their normal work while a pupil observes, asks questions and helps with appropriate tasks. Now consider an employee specifically assigned to teach, train or supervise that pupil throughout the placement. Those arrangements may be different in ways that matter when deciding whether regulated activity is taking place. What matters is understanding what each employee actually does, rather than assuming that either arrangement automatically falls inside or outside the definition.
There is another distinction worth exploring. Most employees will continue to receive their normal wages while supporting a pupil. But being paid while supporting a young person isn’t necessarily the same as being paid to support them. In one workplace, an employee may simply agree to have a pupil alongside them for a week. In another, teaching and training young people may be an established part of someone’s paid responsibilities. This isn’t a separate legal rule, but it is potentially useful information when considering the purpose and nature of the activities involved.
The school needs to understand the arrangements sufficiently well to make an informed decision. Employers don’t need to become experts in safeguarding legislation to help with that.
What Might Schools Ask Employers to do?
I’d suggest that Careers Leaders begin with a clear explanation of why schools need information about placements, followed by a straightforward questionnaire. The questions should concern the work itself, rather than asking employers to decide whether their employees are undertaking regulated activity.
For example, schools could ask employers to describe what the pupil will do during the placement, who will work directly with them and whether those employees will be specifically responsible for teaching, training or supervising them. They could ask whether supporting young people is part of an employee’s normal paid responsibilities or something they are doing alongside their usual work. They could also ask how frequently those employees undertake similar activities with children, including pupils from other schools.
These questions won’t produce a legal answer by themselves. They will provide information that the Careers Leader can review and, where necessary, discuss with the school’s Designated Safeguarding Lead (DSL). Some arrangements may be straightforward. Others will require clarification and more careful consideration. The important thing is that decisions are based on what actually happens during the placement, rather than assumptions about the employer, the industry or the job title.
Where the school concludes that an employee will be undertaking regulated activity, it needs appropriate assurance that the employee is not barred from working with children. Employers also have legal responsibilities: it is a criminal offence to permit someone to undertake regulated activity if you know, or have reason to believe, that they are barred from doing so.
Where a check is needed, the appropriate route for someone undertaking regulated activity is an Enhanced DBS check that includes Children’s Barred List information. Employers can arrange eligible checks through a DBS Umbrella Body, an organisation that processes DBS applications on behalf of others. The employee provides their personal information and receives the certificate, which they can then share with their employer.
The school doesn’t necessarily need to inspect or retain the contents of the certificate. It needs appropriate assurance that the employee is not barred, and that assurance needs a credible basis. The school and employer should agree what confirmation will be provided, who will arrange any necessary check and who will meet the cost.
None of this means that everyone in the workplace must be checked. Nor does a DBS check, by itself, establish that a placement is safe. Schools and employers still need to consider the wider arrangements for safeguarding the young person throughout their experience.
Making This Manageable for Careers Leaders
A Careers Leader coordinating 200 placements cannot reasonably be expected to conduct 200 individual discussions about safeguarding legislation. There needs to be a manageable process that gives employers the information they need, gathers relevant details about placements and identifies those arrangements requiring closer attention.
I would begin by writing to every employer with an accessible explanation of the changes, why the school needs information and what might happen next. I’d offer an information evening or online meeting for employers who want to ask questions. I’d then send a short questionnaire focused on what the pupil and employees will actually be doing.
The Careers Leader and DSL should agree in advance how responses will be reviewed, which circumstances need to be referred for safeguarding consideration and how decisions will be recorded. This allows the Careers Leader to manage the placement process without being expected to make safeguarding judgements independently, while giving the DSL the information needed to consider the more complex cases.
There won’t necessarily be identical decisions in every school, even where placements appear similar. That doesn’t automatically mean one school is right and another is wrong. Professional judgement involves interpreting the available information, applying the relevant legislation and guidance, and being able to explain why a particular decision was reached. What matters is that those judgements are informed, proportionate and defensible.
We also need to remember what this process looks like from the employer’s perspective. A business that has offered placements for years may now be facing unfamiliar terminology, additional administration, possible costs and conversations with employees that it has never previously needed to have. Schools should be prepared to explain what they are asking for and why, listen to employers’ concerns and work with them to find practical solutions. The purpose is to safeguard young people, not to make providing work experience unnecessarily difficult.
Why Work Experience is Good for Business
Careers Leaders need to be able to explain the benefits of work experience to employers just as confidently as they explain the safeguarding requirements. Work experience isn’t simply a favour that businesses do for schools. It can bring real benefits to the businesses and employees who participate.
For employees, working with young people provides opportunities to develop coaching, communication, mentoring and leadership skills. Explaining familiar tasks to someone who has never encountered them before requires patience, clarity and an ability to see your own work from a different perspective. These are skills that have value well beyond the placement itself.
For employers, work experience can help develop a future workforce. A young person who enjoys their placement might become an apprentice or employee, or encourage others to consider an industry they previously knew little about. Businesses can introduce young people to occupations and opportunities they might never otherwise encounter, while developing relationships with local schools and strengthening their presence in the community.
Young people also bring something of their own. They ask questions that experienced employees may have stopped asking, approach familiar problems differently and sometimes offer fresh perspectives on the way a business operates. Giving them meaningful tasks, practical challenges and opportunities to contribute can make the experience more rewarding for everyone involved.
These benefits aren’t simply aspirations. The Department for Education’s careers guidance draws on evidence from employers about the value of well-designed work experience, including its contribution to attracting future employees. It also encourages experiences that involve meaningful participation in working life, rather than simply observing from the sidelines.
Of course, more ambitious placements may involve activities that require closer safeguarding consideration. That should encourage thoughtful planning and collaboration between schools and employers, rather than discourage worthwhile opportunities.
The government’s ambition is to expand meaningful experiences of work. Achieving that ambition depends on employers continuing to offer their time, expertise and workplaces to young people. Careers Leaders have an important role in helping businesses understand not only what is being asked of them, but also what they stand to gain.
Work experience can benefit young people, develop employees, strengthen businesses and create opportunities that might otherwise never exist. Those are compelling reasons for employers to continue opening their doors, and for schools to make the process of doing so as straightforward as possible.
Work experience can benefit young people, develop employees, strengthen businesses and create opportunities that might otherwise never exist. Those are compelling reasons for employers to continue opening their doors, and for schools to make the process of doing so as straightforward as possible. That doesn’t mean compromising on safeguarding. It means understanding the requirements, gathering the right information and making informed professional judgements.
In my final post in this series, I’ll explore the distinction between defensible safeguarding decisions, grounded in evidence, legislation and professional judgement, and defensive decisions, driven primarily by anxiety about accountability.