Insight: Regulated Activity, DBS and Modern Experiences of Work

Post 5: Where Do We Go From Here?

Over the past week, I’ve spent a considerable amount of time exploring the implications of the September 2026 changes to regulated activity for school work experience. I’ve examined legislation and guidance, considered different scenarios, challenged interpretations (including my own), and sought clarification from DBS, DfE and the Careers & Enterprise Company. Some questions remain unanswered, and I’ll share what I learn when those responses arrive.
I’m conscious that I’m in a privileged position to undertake this work. I spent more than a decade working as both a Careers Leader and Designated Safeguarding Lead. Now, as an independent consultant, I have the time and professional motivation to explore a complex issue in detail. Colleagues in schools don’t necessarily have that luxury. Careers Leaders are organising placements, maintaining relationships with employers and supporting young people, while DSLs are managing safeguarding responsibilities alongside everything else their roles demand. That was one reason for writing this series: I wanted to share what I was learning with colleagues who were understandably anxious about the implications.
But I don’t want to finish with uncertainty. I want to finish with what we can do.
Careers Leaders: bring your DSL into the conversation.
If you’re responsible for organising work experience, you may be feeling that questions about regulated activity and DBS have landed squarely on your desk. I suspect part of that discomfort comes from recognising that you’re being asked to make decisions which sit outside your usual professional domain. You understand work experience, what young people actually do on placements and the relationships with employers. But deciding whether an adult’s activities constitute regulated activity, and what DBS checks may be appropriate, requires safeguarding expertise.
Don’t assume, however, that your DSL will immediately have all the answers. They may be less familiar than you are with the particular application of regulated activity legislation to work experience. After all, the activities young people undertake in workplaces are your professional territory, not necessarily theirs. Be prepared to explain what those activities involve, how placements are organised and why the changes have raised questions. I hope this series has helped you develop the understanding and confidence to have that conversation.
Equally, be prepared to explain why this isn’t a decision the Careers Leader should be expected to make alone. The assessment of regulated activity and the decisions about appropriate safeguarding checks and assurances require the involvement of the school’s safeguarding lead. That’s not an attempt to pass responsibility elsewhere; it’s about recognising where different professional responsibilities sit. Again, I hope this series has helped make that distinction clearer.
Perhaps the most useful thing we can do is improve our understanding of the placements themselves. For years, the enormous logistical challenge of finding placements for an entire year group may have encouraged us to focus on where pupils are going rather than precisely what they will experience. Yet the information we need to assess regulated activity — what activities will take place, which adults will be involved and how — is also information that can help us evaluate the educational quality of those experiences. By gathering it more systematically, we can make better safeguarding decisions and better career education decisions.
Once you’ve established that shared understanding, agree what information you need from employers, how placements will be assessed, who will make and record decisions, and what assurances will be sought. If you’re working with 200 employers, that doesn’t mean your DSL needs to conduct 200 individual assessments from scratch. A clear communication explaining the changes, an opportunity for employers to ask questions, and a short factual questionnaire about the activities pupils will undertake and the adults involved could help establish a manageable process. Careers Leaders can coordinate the information-gathering and identify cases requiring closer consideration, while DSLs can apply their expertise to the safeguarding questions those cases raise. The aim is a proportionate, workable process, not another administrative mountain.
DSLs: bring your professional judgement, not a blanket rule.
The removal of the supervision exemption does not mean that every adult working alongside a pupil on work experience is automatically undertaking regulated activity. The actual activities, circumstances and statutory conditions matter. Nor can a school create DBS eligibility simply by deciding that it would prefer everyone to have a certificate. Your Careers Leader needs your professional expertise in assessing these circumstances, explaining the reasoning and recording defensible decisions.
Consider a familiar safeguarding situation. On a Monday morning, a child is absent from school and there has been no contact from home. The DSL arranges a home visit, considers the information returned and decides whether further action, including a referral, is necessary. Now imagine the same situation on the Friday before a two-week holiday. The DSL might decide to make an immediate referral while still arranging the visit, because there is much less time to gather information and respond before the school closes. The presenting concern is identical, but the context is different. Both decisions may be entirely defensible.
We accept that safeguarding requires professional judgement informed by context, evidence and experience. We should apply that same principle when assessing work experience. A defensible decision isn’t necessarily the most restrictive one; it’s one grounded in the law, the evidence and sound professional reasoning.
Work with employers, not simply through them.
Employers are partners in providing educational opportunities, and we need them to continue welcoming young people into their workplaces. Where a placement involves regulated activity, additional arrangements may be needed, including appropriate checks and assurances. My current reading of the legislation is that the employer ordinarily has responsibility for establishing that an employee undertaking regulated activity is not barred, while the school seeks appropriate assurances. I’ve asked DBS to clarify the respective responsibilities, including who may request checks and who is entitled to see certificates.
In the meantime, schools can prepare to work constructively with employers. Explain the changes, discuss the arrangements that may be needed and consider how the school could help with applications, administration or costs where checks are appropriate. The legal responsibilities and the practical arrangements for meeting them are not necessarily the same thing. We should be making employers’ involvement as straightforward as we reasonably can.
And now, let’s talk about career education.
A colleague responding to an earlier post explained that they were about to launch Year 10 work experience and didn’t feel sufficiently confident explaining the requirements to pupils, parents and employers. Their school was planning to reduce placements from five days to three, but having read the series, they were questioning whether even that went far enough. I suggested that shortening placements might be a reasonable short-term response to uncertainty, particularly if it meant young people wouldn’t miss out on work experience altogether. But the exchange raised a much wider question for me: why are we allowing uncertainty about regulated activity to determine the length and structure of placements in the first place? What are we actually trying to achieve through work experience?
I’m not particularly attached to the traditional five-day placement with a single employer. In fact, as a career development professional, I can see compelling reasons to offer young people multiple experiences of the workplace. Donald Super’s career development theory identifies adolescence as a period of exploration, during which young people begin to develop and test their understanding of themselves and the working world. John Krumboltz emphasises the role of learning experiences and unexpected encounters in shaping career development. Our understanding of adolescent development also points towards the value of encountering unfamiliar environments, people and possibilities.
At 14 or 15, young people don’t necessarily need to have settled on an occupation, and nor should we expect them to. They need opportunities to discover what exists, meet people whose work they’ve never considered, encounter organisations and sectors they know little about, challenge assumptions about particular jobs and discover interests and possibilities they hadn’t imagined. Five days with one employer can be wonderful, but so could three days with one employer complemented by meaningful encounters with several others. The educational argument isn’t that three days is better than five. It’s that multiple experiences can offer a breadth of exploration that a singular experience cannot.
The latest DfE careers guidance supports that ambition. The strengthened Gatsby Benchmark 6 emphasises multiple, meaningful and varied experiences of workplaces, while the government’s two-weeks-worth approach allows the five days of placement experience in Years 10 and 11 to be organised flexibly across one or more employers. There is no requirement for five consecutive days with a single employer.
Which raises an interesting historical question. Why have we become so attached to the traditional five-day model? When work-related learning was statutory at Key Stage 4, the legislation didn’t prescribe five consecutive days with one employer. Perhaps the school timetable, administrative convenience and inherited practice have shaped our approach more than we’ve realised. And perhaps this is a good moment to reconsider it.
The important distinction is why we make decisions about programme design. Are we designing experiences around what young people need to explore and learn, or are we shortening placements because we’re anxious about the compliance implications of regulated activity? A three-day placement might be an entirely reasonable short-term response to uncertainty, and it might also form part of an excellent long-term programme. But those are two very different justifications. The risk isn’t necessarily that three days is less meaningful than five; it’s that anxiety about compliance displaces educational reasoning from decisions about the curriculum.
School leaders: create the conditions for this to work.
Careers Leaders shouldn’t be left making safeguarding decisions alone, and DSLs shouldn’t find themselves determining the educational design of work experience simply because safeguarding questions have arisen. Both professions bring essential expertise. School leaders can ensure that expertise is brought together, that sufficient time and resources are available, and that carefully reasoned decisions are supported. We don’t need every school to arrive at identical arrangements. We need schools to understand the legislation, make defensible decisions, work constructively with employers and keep the educational purpose firmly in view.
I’ve spent much of this series examining what safeguarding legislation permits, requires and expects. But the Careers Leader in me wants to finish by asking something different. What do we actually want young people to gain from work experience? What opportunities should we be opening up for them? What assumptions might we help them challenge? And are we prepared to organise ourselves, as professionals and institutions, around those educational ambitions?
The September changes have created some genuine practical challenges, and we still need clarity on aspects of their implementation. But they also give us a reason to bring safeguarding and career education professionals together, review inherited practice and think ambitiously about the opportunities we provide.
We shouldn’t design work experience to avoid regulated activity. We should design meaningful work experience and establish the safeguarding arrangements needed to deliver it.
That’s a positive challenge for Careers Leaders, DSLs, employers and school leaders alike. And it’s one worth embracing.

Scroll to Top