Insight: Regulated Activity, DBS and Modern Work Experience.

Postscript: Careers Leaders or Careers Labourers?

One of the most interesting aspects of the responses to my recent posts about work experience and DBS wasn’t disagreement about the legislation. It was the frustration expressed by some Careers Leaders about their capacity to respond to it. Workload, time, resources, established ways of working and the sheer difficulty of changing a programme that already takes enormous effort to deliver were recurring themes. I recognise that frustration, and it has made me reflect on a question that deserves to be directed not at Careers Leaders, but at the senior leaders of our schools. Have we appointed Careers Leaders, but created Careers Labourers?

Of course, this is not the experience of every Careers Leader. Some hold senior leadership positions, with the authority to influence whole-school decisions. Others work with dedicated careers teams, administrators, advisers and colleagues who take responsibility for substantial elements of operational delivery. Some enjoy protected time for strategic planning, established curriculum provision and the active support of their headteacher and governors. These arrangements will look different from school to school, and a place on the senior leadership team is no guarantee of strategic capacity, just as its absence does not necessarily prevent effective leadership.

But that variation is precisely the point. Where Careers Leaders have the time, authority and support to lead, it is often because somebody has made deliberate decisions about the organisation of careers education. Responsibilities have been distributed, resources allocated, structures established and careers given a meaningful place within whole-school planning. The distinction between the Careers Leader and the heroic Careers Labourer is therefore not simply a reflection of individual capability, commitment or resilience. It is, at least in part, a consequence of decisions made by school leadership.

A narrow change, a bigger problem

The legislative changes that prompted my original posts were relatively narrow. Understanding their implications, however, was anything but straightforward. The legislation, DBS eligibility rules and statutory safeguarding guidance required careful reading, and their application to work experience raised practical questions that were not always answered clearly by the relevant agencies. It took considerable time to work through the distinctions, test assumptions and establish what schools actually needed to do. That is not a criticism of Careers Leaders who found the process difficult. It is precisely the sort of complex professional problem that leaders should have the time, support and professional networks to investigate.

What struck me about some of the responses was that the difficulty went beyond interpreting the legislation. Careers Leaders described being so consumed by existing responsibilities that they had little capacity to investigate the changes, let alone adapt their programmes in response. Yet the practical adjustments, once the relevant distinctions had been understood, were not necessarily revolutionary. Schools needed to identify where regulated activity might arise, communicate clearly with employers, establish appropriate checking and assurance arrangements, and record defensible decisions. There were important details to resolve, including who could obtain the relevant checks and how schools could secure appropriate assurance, but the underlying approach was familiar to anyone accustomed to managing safeguarding responsibilities.

That is what makes the level of anxiety expressed in some responses particularly troubling. If a relatively narrow legislative change, albeit one accompanied by difficult guidance and genuine uncertainty, is sufficient to push an already stretched Careers Leader from just about managing to feeling unable to cope, the issue deserves attention well beyond the careers department. The problem is no longer simply the additional work created by the legislation. It is the absence of capacity within the existing system to accommodate change.

Safeguarding makes this example particularly revealing. Schools are rightly expected to take safeguarding seriously, and changes that might affect the safety of young people should command attention. If even this cannot create the space for investigation, discussion and considered action, what happens when the need for change is less urgent, less visible or less obviously connected to statutory responsibilities? What opportunity is there to respond thoughtfully to changes in the labour market, developments in careers education, the evolving needs of pupils or evidence that an established activity is no longer effective?

There are surprisingly few MUSTs

One of the things that strikes me whenever I return to the legislation and statutory guidance governing careers education is how few absolute statutory requirements there actually are. We have developed a substantial framework of expectations, benchmarks, programmes, events and activities, but it is worth distinguishing what schools are legally obliged to do from the professional choices they make about how to deliver excellent careers education.

For maintained secondary schools and academies in England, the principal legal duties and associated requirements can be summarised relatively briefly:

  1. Independent careers guidance. Schools must secure independent, impartial careers guidance for pupils throughout secondary education, covering the required range of education and training options and provided in pupils’ best interests.
  2. Provider access. Schools must provide the required opportunities for pupils to encounter providers of technical education and apprenticeships, including the six qualifying encounters across Years 8–13 where applicable, subject to the statutory conditions.
  3. A provider access policy. Schools must prepare and publish the required policy statement explaining their arrangements for provider access.
  4. Published careers information. Schools must meet the applicable requirements to publish information about their careers programme, including its content, leadership and evaluation. The precise legal basis differs between maintained schools and academies.
  5. Statutory guidance. Schools must have regard to the relevant DfE statutory guidance when carrying out their duties. Recommendations expressed as SHOULD deserve serious consideration and should not be disregarded without good reason.

This is not an exhaustive account of every obligation applying to every institution, but the list is strikingly short compared with the breadth of activities that typically make up a careers programme. The Gatsby Benchmarks provide an internationally respected, evidence-informed framework for developing excellent provision, and the DfE expects schools to work towards them. But the Benchmarks are not themselves eight statutory duties, nor do they prescribe a particular calendar of activities. The distinction matters because it leaves schools considerable scope to exercise professional judgement about how best to meet the needs of their young people.

That freedom should create an exciting opportunity for Careers Leaders. Beyond the statutory foundations and the expectations of guidance, schools can determine the knowledge, experiences, confidence and capabilities they want their students to develop, and then design provision to achieve those outcomes. The activities should follow from those decisions, rather than becoming the starting point themselves. This is not an argument for minimum compliance. A genuinely ambitious careers programme will go considerably beyond the legal baseline, but it should do so through purposeful educational design rather than simply accumulating more activity.

Programmes built around the gaps

In practice, careers programmes have histories. An enthusiastic colleague introduces an activity. A Careers Leader develops a relationship with an employer. A successful event becomes an annual fixture. Staffing changes, funding disappears, COVID forces a compromise, and temporary arrangements become permanent. Over time, programmes accumulate activities, traditions, commitments and expectations. Some are excellent, some may have outlived their original purpose, and others continue because nobody has had the opportunity to ask whether there might be a better way.

Careers education also occupies an unusual position within the school curriculum. In schools without dedicated careers teaching or substantial administrative support, Careers Leaders may find themselves planning provision around whatever opportunities the timetable offers. They fit activities into tutor periods, occasional curriculum slots, drop-down days, collapsed timetables and opportunities created by examination seasons. Their programmes must accommodate the priorities of other subjects, departments and school leaders, often with little opportunity to influence those priorities themselves. Few schools would be expected to organise their entire curriculum around careers education, nor would that necessarily be desirable. But it is worth asking what genuine strategic control looks like when so much of the programme must be negotiated around everybody else’s priorities.

Even when curriculum time is available, the Careers Leader may have little control over how it is used. They may be writing lessons and preparing resources for delivery by colleagues who are neither careers specialists nor necessarily enthusiastic about taking on another responsibility. Those colleagues may themselves be under considerable pressure, with their own curriculum demands and competing priorities. The Careers Leader remains responsible for the quality of the provision, but has limited influence over the conditions in which it is delivered. They are expected to lead a programme without necessarily having the staffing, curriculum time or authority that we would ordinarily associate with curriculum leadership.

None of this necessarily means that a school undervalues careers education. Timetables are finite, specialist staff are expensive and schools must balance many legitimate educational priorities. But those constraints are organisational realities that senior leaders must recognise and manage. They cannot simply be handed to the Careers Leader as problems to overcome through persistence, negotiation and goodwill. If careers education is a whole-school responsibility, its delivery must be supported by whole-school structures, rather than depending almost entirely on the resourcefulness of one individual.

The heroic Careers Leader

And that brings us to the heroic Careers Leader. The person who knows the employers, understands the students, sorts out the placements, organises the encounters, negotiates with colleagues, updates the records, deals with cancellations and somehow makes everything happen. Schools are fortunate to have people like this, but there is a danger in becoming dependent on their heroism. A programme that succeeds because of an exceptional individual is not necessarily a programme supported by an effective system. Indeed, the more effective that individual becomes at keeping everything running, the less obvious the need for the school to change the arrangements around them.

Management theorists have explored these tensions for decades. John Kotter distinguished between management, which brings order and consistency to complex organisations, and leadership, which establishes direction and enables change. Michael Lipsky examined how professionals delivering public services adapt to limited resources and competing demands, developing practical routines that can ultimately shape the services they provide. Both offer useful ways of thinking about careers education. When almost all of a Careers Leader’s capacity is devoted to maintaining existing provision, the programme risks becoming defined by what it already does rather than what it is intended to achieve. Workload becomes more than an obstacle to change; it can become a consequence of the failure to change. Existing activities generate demands, those demands consume the capacity needed to review them, and so the activities continue.

The distinction between responsibility and authority is equally important. Schools may hold Careers Leaders accountable for the quality and impact of their programmes without giving them meaningful control over the time, staffing, resources or organisational decisions that determine how those programmes are delivered. A Head of English would ordinarily expect timetabled lessons, subject teachers and some influence over curriculum delivery. A Careers Leader may be expected to achieve comparable coherence and quality through a patchwork of negotiated opportunities and the goodwill of colleagues. This is not simply a workload problem. It is a question of organisational design, and one that senior leaders are uniquely placed to address.

Creating the space to lead

The recent discussion about work experience, regulated activity and DBS provides a timely illustration. The legislative change was narrow, but interpreting it required time, care and professional judgement. Responding to it required schools to review arrangements, communicate expectations and make defensible decisions. None of that should be beyond the capacity of a school with effective leadership structures. Yet some of the responses suggested that even relatively modest adjustments felt overwhelming because the people responsible were already operating at the limits of their capacity.

And that raises an uncomfortable question. If the person appointed to lead careers education has neither the time to examine a significant change nor the authority and resources to make adjustments in response, in what meaningful sense are they being enabled to lead? We cannot reasonably expect Careers Leaders to exercise professional judgement, maintain compliance, evaluate provision and respond to emerging challenges while simultaneously occupying every available moment with the operational demands of the existing programme. Something has to give, and too often it appears to be the opportunity to think.

Perhaps the starting point should be a genuine back-to-basics review. What does the law actually require us to provide? What does the statutory guidance expect us to consider? What do we want our young people to know, understand, experience and be able to do as a result of their careers education? How can we use the Gatsby Benchmarks and other evidence to inform our choices? Only then should we ask what activities, encounters, guidance and experiences our programme needs to include. Starting with the intended outcomes rather than the existing calendar creates the opportunity to make deliberate decisions about what to retain, improve, introduce or stop.

This isn’t an argument for dismantling established programmes or dismissing the achievements of Careers Leaders who have spent years developing them. Nor is it a suggestion that every non-statutory activity is optional in any meaningful educational sense. A genuinely ambitious careers programme will go considerably beyond minimum legal compliance. But ambition should be expressed through purposeful design, not simply through the accumulation of more activity. And the professional best placed to help lead that design must have the time, authority and support to do so.

Some schools have already created careers leadership roles with genuine strategic authority, appropriate operational support and the capacity to adapt. Others continue to rely heavily on exceptional individuals to keep increasingly complex programmes running. The difference is not necessarily the quality of the Careers Leader. It may be the decisions the school has made about how careers education is organised, resourced and led.

So perhaps the most useful question for headteachers, principals, governors and trust leaders isn’t whether their Careers Leader is doing enough. It is whether the school has created the conditions in which careers education can be genuinely led. When did your leadership team last give your Careers Leader the opportunity to step away from the demands of delivery, examine what the school is trying to achieve and question whether the existing programme remains the best way of achieving it? And when they identify something that needs to change, do they have the authority and organisational support to make that change happen?

There are surprisingly few statutory MUSTs in careers education, and considerable scope to design a programme that reflects the needs and ambitions of a school community. But that freedom belongs to the school as an institution. Unless senior leaders share it meaningfully with the professionals they have appointed to lead careers education, it remains largely theoretical.

The question for school leaders is not whether their Careers Leader is doing enough, but why doing enough requires so much of them.

Scroll to Top